Knowing that the link will be opened in the same window, a new tab, or new window Just call me Keanu
Feb 18

Smart way around spam: ask humans to do something different with the same data

Tech Add comments

I somehow haven’t noticed the form of spam avoidance than Joe Gregorio uses on his blog.

Instead of asking for some inane piece of information (CAPTCHA) he simply asks for your name and email || website in a special format: bob (email) or bob (websiteurl).

This is so simple and smart in that most blogs ask for this anyway, but it is different enough that spam bots won’t know about it yet (hopefully). If they grok it you can just change the format (e.g. bob [email]).

More hackable than a “your site specific” logic CAPTCHA, but it does have the nice effect of being obscure, and hopefully it will stay that way.

commenterformatting.png

One Response to “Smart way around spam: ask humans to do something different with the same data”

  1. Brian McCallister Says:

    I’ve had a pretty good run of asking people to correct a spelling mistake. I suspect it works not because it is clever, though, but because it only applies to one blog, and that blog is not popular enough to warrant someone looking at how to make the bots work against it.

    That solves my problem, however :-)

Leave a Reply

Spam is a pain, I am sorry to have to do this to you, but can you answer the question below?

Q: What is the number before 3? (just put in the digit)