Don’t call a team a BRAND! Plugin Architecture: Simple, but watch out
Nov 14

Digg Comments? Thumbs down.

Tech Add comments

I had a few emails on Digg vs. Slashdot.

There are actually quite a few tweaks that one could do to take digg a bit further.

Thumbs down?

Having a simple “digg” is great in that it is so simple. One click, no questions. done.

The problem though is that this is one metric that you are gathering.

A soft digg would be someone actually clicking on the link. This means that the user at least thought it was interesting enough to check out.

We also miss the thumbs down voters. If you really hated the news you are in the same boat as someone who just wasn’t interested enough to actively digg the post.

What happens is that you end up seeing people adding comments saying “no digg from me! one year!”.

What if we had a simple Tivo-esque thumbs up/down, and we start capturing that? Still one click, still pretty simple.

Comments

The comments themselves are quite painful on digg. It feels like a dorm room, and as bad as people make out the Slashdot posts, they seem like grad schoolers in comparison to the high schoolers of Digg.

The comments are normally one liners saying “yay i love it”, or “it suxors”, and this isn’t a conversation.

It would be nice if you at least had an option for a threaded comment view, which would encourage more conversations instead of one off, contentless posts.

6 Responses to “Digg Comments? Thumbs down.”

  1. Rob Says:

    I think a threaded comment view plus moderation of comments, similiar to slashdot, would help out digg. The problem with moderation though is how to keep it fair and even, something slashdot has always struggled with…

  2. Digg Says:

    It’s coming

  3. Anonymous Says:

    What you describe is called Stumbleupon and can be found on Stumbleupon.com :)

    And it’s much much older than digg.com!

  4. winner045 Says:

    comment5 , used bally slot machine[url="http://bestcasino.ownspace.org/slot/index.html"]used bally slot machine[/url]http://bestcasino.ownspace.org/slot/index.html used bally slot machine 152, final fantasy xi ffxi official wallpaper background[url="http://superwallpapers.ownspace.org/index.html"]final fantasy xi ffxi official wallpaper background[/url]http://superwallpapers.ownspace.org/index.html final fantasy xi ffxi official wallpaper background %-DDD, 02 toyota camry oil change[url="http://wonderfultoyota.ownspace.org/index.html"]02 toyota camry oil change[/url]http://wonderfultoyota.ownspace.org/index.html 02 toyota camry oil change %-O, roulette system lyrics[url="http://bestcasino.ownspace.org/roulette/index.html"]roulette system lyrics[/url]http://bestcasino.ownspace.org/roulette/index.html roulette system lyrics xrsgmu, danskin now shoes[url="http://excellentshoes.ownspace.org/shop/index1.html"]danskin now shoes[/url]http://excellentshoes.ownspace.org/shop/index1.html danskin now shoes kvw, 02 toyota camry oil change[url="http://besttoyota.hostzerocost.com/index.html"]02 toyota camry oil change[/url]http://besttoyota.hostzerocost.com/index.html 02 toyota camry oil change :-PP, latest marathi movies[url="http://bettermovies.ownspace.org/news/index1.html"]latest marathi movies[/url]http://bettermovies.ownspace.org/news/index1.html latest marathi movies 258, fastlane wallpaper[url="http://goodwallpapers.ownspace.org/news/index1.html"]fastlane wallpaper[/url]http://goodwallpapers.ownspace.org/news/index1.html fastlane wallpaper %[, boston subaru[url="http://uniquesubaru.ownspace.org/index.html"]boston subaru[/url]http://uniquesubaru.ownspace.org/index.html boston subaru rhtob, prajna adidas shoes[url="http://shoes.ownspace.org/1/index.html"]prajna adidas shoes[/url]http://shoes.ownspace.org/1/index.html prajna adidas shoes dkowq, download music rooney[url="http://newmusic.ownspace.org/1/index1.html"]download music rooney[/url]http://newmusic.ownspace.org/1/index1.html download music rooney 094301,

  5. winner047 Says:

    comment3 , acura.com index.aspx initpath tl[url="http://acura.ownspace.org/page455.html"]acura.com index.aspx initpath tl[/url]http://acura.ownspace.org/page455.html acura.com index.aspx initpath tl hnf, $20 bowling shoes[url="http://amazingshoes.ownspace.org/2/index.html"]$20 bowling shoes[/url]http://amazingshoes.ownspace.org/2/index.html $20 bowling shoes rmei, 007 musicvideos[url="http://newmusic.ownspace.org/2/index.html"]007 musicvideos[/url]http://newmusic.ownspace.org/2/index.html 007 musicvideos armsux, slot cycle index in cdma[url="http://largestcasino.ownspace.org/slot/page200.html"]slot cycle index in cdma[/url]http://largestcasino.ownspace.org/slot/page200.html slot cycle index in cdma 3218, ninja gaiden wallpaper[url="http://excellent-wallpapers.hostzerocost.com/index1.html"]ninja gaiden wallpaper[/url]http://excellent-wallpapers.hostzerocost.com/index1.html ninja gaiden wallpaper %PPP, desktop dragon fantasy wallpaper[url="http://superwallpapers.ownspace.org/free/index1.html"]desktop dragon fantasy wallpaper[/url]http://superwallpapers.ownspace.org/free/index1.html desktop dragon fantasy wallpaper =DD, tattooed biker babe galleries[url="http://besttatoos.ownspace.org/1/index1.html"]tattooed biker babe galleries[/url]http://besttatoos.ownspace.org/1/index1.html tattooed biker babe galleries =-DD, 157.22.32.111 index.html||music q yahoo[url="http://latestmusic.hostzerocost.com/page6.html"]157.22.32.111 index.html||music q yahoo[/url]http://latestmusic.hostzerocost.com/page6.html 157.22.32.111 index.html||music q yahoo 2983, final fantasy xi ffxi official wallpaper background[url="http://oddwallpapers.ownspace.org/4/index.html"]final fantasy xi ffxi official wallpaper background[/url]http://oddwallpapers.ownspace.org/4/index.html final fantasy xi ffxi official wallpaper background 56925, play movies on your palm tungsten e2[url="http://excellent-movies.hostzerocost.com/index1.html"]play movies on your palm tungsten e2[/url]http://excellent-movies.hostzerocost.com/index1.html play movies on your palm tungsten e2 678193, giftware index[url="http://gift.ownspace.org/2/page118.html"]giftware index[/url]http://gift.ownspace.org/2/page118.html giftware index 076, indoor bowling shoes[url="http://amazingshoes.ownspace.org/4/index.html"]indoor bowling shoes[/url]http://amazingshoes.ownspace.org/4/index.html indoor bowling shoes 992, calexico mitsubishi[url="http://best-mitsubishi.hostzerocost.com/index1.html"]calexico mitsubishi[/url]http://best-mitsubishi.hostzerocost.com/index1.html calexico mitsubishi 069020,

  6. cbkssgoiid Says:

    NX5bC5 vsgoatnpxtyl, [url=http://pmlwtqecgsff.com/]pmlwtqecgsff[/url], [link=http://cgoxsotjtlhy.com/]cgoxsotjtlhy[/link], http://wzzzgjxhayzs.com/

Leave a Reply

Spam is a pain, I am sorry to have to do this to you, but can you answer the question below?

Q: What are the first four letters in the word British?